#91 Debate: Does Objective Morality Require God? | Benjamin Blake Speed Watkins vs. Joel Settecase

Worldview Legacy | The Think Institute

You're about to see the Transcendental Argument for God in action when atheism and Christianity collide. In this compelling episode of the Worldview Legacy podcast, Joel Settecase steps into the hot seat on the "Real Atheology, a Philosophy of Religion Podcast," hosted by Benjamin Blake Speed Watkins. The conversation centers around one of the most profound questions in moral philosophy: Does Objective Morality Require God? Join Joel and Ben as they engage in a rigorous and respectful dialogue, exploring their contrasting views on the nature of morality and meta-ethics. Ben presents his case for ethical non-naturalism, arguing that objective moral values can exist independently of God. Joel counters by grounding moral truths in the very nature of God, asserting that without a divine being, objective morality lacks a coherent foundation. Key Topics Covered: The distinction between moral values and moral obligations. Ethical non-naturalism vs. theistic moral realism. The relationship between general and special revelation in understanding morality. The coherence (or incoherence) of abstract moral propositions without a divine mind. Joel’s challenge to atheism and the implications of God’s necessary existence for morality and knowledge. The episode concludes with a thought-provoking challenge from Joel, inviting listeners to consider the Christian worldview and its robust answers to the moral questions that shape our lives. 🚀 Takeaways: Gain a deeper understanding of the debate on objective morality. Learn about different perspectives on the source of moral truths. Explore the philosophical and theological implications of a godless morality vs. a theistic moral framework. Don't miss this engaging episode that tackles one of the most debated questions in the philosophy of religion! 🔗 Resources Mentioned: Real Atheology, a Philosophy of Religion Podcast: https://www.youtube.com/@UCQa6mPLOE2yuMCrDjRio_nA The Think Institute website: https://thethink.institute 🎧 Listen to the full episode now! ---- Take your learning further with the Hammer & Anvil Society, our men's learning fellowship. Learn more at https://thethink.institute/society. Chapters: 00:00 Introduction and Guest Introduction 01:58 Discussing Moral Philosophy 04:32 Christian Perspective on Moral Obligations 11:01 Epistemology and Abstract Entities 27:11 Exploring the Problem of the One and the Many 29:18 The Triune God and Metaphysical Mysteries 31:24 Philosophical Debates on God's Existence 44:19 Final Thoughts and Reflections