No Lowballers - America’s Guns Are Boring

Sportsmen's Empire - Western Big Game Hunting

In this episode of the No Lowballers Podcast, hosts Logan Metesh of High Caliber History and Allen Forkner of GunBroker take a humorous yet introspective look at the top-selling guns in America, as listed on GunGenius.com. Allen passionately laments how America’s love for individuality seems to have been lost in the “cookie-cutter” world of black polymer handguns and standard-issue rifles. Together, they explore alternatives that bring back personality and flair, offering nostalgic nods to history and unique suggestions for modern firearm enthusiasts.

Links: Logan discusses the FrankenColt: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QjrlfpoFtXg

See the whole list at Gun Genius: https://genius.gunbroker.com/top-selling/

America’s Boring Bestsellers:

The dominance of black polymer handguns like the SIG P365, Glock 19, and SIG P320.

Rifles such as the Ruger 10/22 and the Marlin 1895 taking top spots.

Breaking the Mold:

Allen and Logan’s suggestions for standout alternatives: Colt Pocket Hammerless, Smith & Wesson Model 29, pre-64 Winchester Model 70, and more.

Lever-action shotguns and unique classics like the Stevens Visible Loader for a touch of flair.

The Case for Personality in Guns:

Why historical pieces like the Winchester 1895 in .405 Winchester or a Browning Auto-5 tell a richer story.

The importance of choosing firearms that reflect individuality and not just practicality.

The “Milkshake” Philosophy:

Guns as more than tools—embracing the fun, beauty, and uniqueness of firearms that stand out in a sea of sameness.

Making a Statement:

Why a Taurus Judge or a classic 1887 lever-action shotgun is the ultimate way to turn heads at the range.

The allure of owning firearms with historical significance or quirky design elements.

Check out the full list of top-selling firearms on GunGenius.com and let us know in the comments what you think of America’s choices. Did you contribute to the “boring” list, or do you have a unique alternative in your collection? Share this episode with friends, leave us a review, and join us next time for more laughs and insights!

The No Lowballers Podcast explores the history and heritage of firearms. We hope to expose you to the vintage guns of the golden age along with newer, modern guns, specialty items, and a few other odd balls along the way. Jump in and come along!